Key Takeaways
- Any rejection based in whole or in part on a consumer credit or background report triggers mandatory federal adverse action disclosures.
- Under Texas Property Code § 92.351 (last checked March 2025), you may retain a reasonable application fee to cover actual screening costs, but you must refund an application deposit if you reject the applicant.
- Texas Property Code § 92.006 (last checked March 2025) prevents landlords from waiving statutory deposit rules inside residential leases or application forms.
- When adverse screening information originates from a non-agency third party rather than a reporting agency, applicants have 60 days to request the nature of the data, and you have 30 days to disclose it.
- Reconstructing your decision with dated, verifiable verification notes rebuts claims of arbitrary or unlawful selection standards.
Required Disclosures for Denials Under Texas Law
When denying a Texas rental applicant based on a consumer report, federal law requires written or electronic adverse action disclosures naming the reporting agency, their dispute rights, and credit score factors. Under Texas Property Code § 92.351 (last checked March 2025), you may retain actual screening fees, but you must immediately refund any application deposit collected.
Statutory Summary (TX · Checked 2026-11-15)
Governing Law: Tex. Prop. Code §§ 92.3515, 92.352 & 92.354
Timing / Window: Notice at intake · 7-day deemed rejection clock
Caps & Thresholds: Bad faith failure to refund: $100 + 3x fee + fees
The Legal Mechanics of an Adverse Action Notice
When you self-manage one to five rental properties in Texas, personal liability rests on your shoulders. Corporate property management firms rely on commercial errors-and-omissions insurance to cushion administrative missteps. An independent owner operating under an individual name or a single-member LLC carries that exposure directly. When a formal demand arrives in your mailbox, every tenant screening decision you executed creates an evidentiary trail that either defends your position or leaves you answering statutory claims.
Federal law regulates how you communicate an applicant rejection whenever third-party data informs your choice. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681a(k), an adverse action is any action taken in connection with an application initiated by a consumer that runs contrary to their interests. Denying an application outright constitutes an adverse action. Demanding a higher security deposit, requiring an extra month of advance rent, or mandating a co-signer based on screening data also constitutes an adverse action under the statute.
If your decision relies in whole or in part on data from a consumer report, 15 U.S.C. § 1681m mandates that you issue an adverse action notice in oral, written, or electronic form. Written or electronic delivery provides the only verifiable record of statutory adherence.
Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, your notice must contain four explicit statutory disclosures:
- Consumer Reporting Agency Identification: The name, physical address, and telephone number (including a toll-free number if available) of the consumer reporting agency that compiled the report.
- Disclaimed Decision Authority: An express statement that the consumer reporting agency did not make the decision to reject the applicant and cannot explain the specific reasons why the adverse action was taken.
- 60-Day Free Report Right: Direct notice that the applicant holds the statutory right under 15 U.S.C. § 1681j to request a free copy of their consumer report from the reporting agency within a 60-day window following receipt of your notice.
- Statutory Dispute Rights: Direct notice that the applicant holds the right under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i to dispute the accuracy or omissions in any information contained in the report directly with the agency.
If you factored a numerical credit score into your decision, 15 U.S.C. § 1681m requires additional transparency. You must disclose the numerical score used, the range of possible scores, the identity of the scoring model provider, the date the score was calculated, and the key statutory factors that adversely affected the score.
Sending an informal rejection by text message fails to deliver these mandatory statutory components. A casual text message stating you selected someone else strips the applicant of their statutory dispute rights and leaves you without proof of statutory performance. To examine the financial and legal ramifications of unrecorded informal notices, review Texting a Tenant Rejection: What the FCRA Requires.
Before you reject an applicant based on raw background data, examine what commercial screening products actually contain. Public record databases frequently conflate individuals with identical names or report expunged records. Reading What a Tenant Background Check Does Not Tell You, and helps you separate actionable background findings from data errors.
Rejections Based on Non-Agency Third Parties: The 60-Day / 30-Day Rule
Landlords frequently verify applicants outside of automated credit bureaus. You may contact prior housing providers, check personal character references, or speak directly with supervisors.
When you deny an applicant based on information obtained from a third party other than a consumer reporting agency—such as a former landlord reporting unauthorized occupants or property damage—federal law imposes a different disclosure mechanism under 15 U.S.C. § 1681m.
In this scenario, you must communicate the rejection and disclose the applicant’s right to make a written request regarding the nature of the third-party information. The statutory clock runs on two specific deadlines:
- Applicant Request Window: The applicant must submit a written request for the nature of the information within 60 days of receiving your adverse action notice.
- Landlord Disclosure Deadline: Once you receive that written request, you have no later than 30 days to disclose the nature of the information upon which the rejection was based.
You do not need to deliver an exhaustive transcript of your conversations, but you must disclose the substantive facts that informed your adverse decision. Documenting what you heard and when you heard it remains necessary. To structure your verification workflows with employers and avoid unverified assumptions, consult Employment Verification: What a Call Confirms.
Texas Property Code Intake Rules: Fees vs. Deposits
Texas Property Code Chapter 92 governs residential landlord and tenant relationships across the state (last checked March 2025). The statute draws a clear line between fees collected to review an application and deposits collected to hold a property or secure a lease.
| FUND TYPE | STATUTORY DEFINITION | PERMISSIBLE USE | DISPOSITION ON DENIAL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Application Fee | Tex. Prop. Code § 92.351 | Offsetting actual screening costs | Nonrefundable |
| Application Deposit | Tex. Prop. Code § 92.351 | Advance funds tied to application | Must be refunded to applicant |
| Security Deposit | Tex. Prop. Code § 92.102 | Securing lease obligations | Governed by Subchapter C; non-waivable |
Application Fees: Tex. Prop. Code § 92.351
Under Texas Property Code § 92.351 (last checked March 2025), an application fee is a nonrefundable sum of money given to the landlord to offset the actual costs of screening an applicant for acceptance as a tenant. You may retain this fee even if you reject the applicant, provided you utilized the funds to cover legitimate screening expenses such as credit report pulls, criminal background checks, or administrative verification processes.
Application Deposits: Tex. Prop. Code § 92.351
Texas Property Code § 92.351 defines an application deposit as a sum of money given to the landlord in connection with a rental application that is refundable to the applicant if the applicant is rejected as a tenant.
Self-managing landlords often blur this distinction by collecting a holding fee alongside the application. Under Texas law, if an advance payment is collected to hold the unit while the application is under review, that sum functions as an application deposit. If you reject the applicant, retaining an application deposit violates Texas Property Code § 92.351. You must return that money promptly.
Security Deposits: Tex. Prop. Code § 92.102
Texas Property Code § 92.102 defines a security deposit as any advance of money, other than an application deposit or advance payment of rent, intended primarily to secure performance under a lease of a dwelling entered into by a landlord and tenant. Under Texas Property Code § 92.006 (last checked March 2025), statutory duties and remedies concerning security deposits cannot be waived in the lease agreement or screening application. If an applicant never signs an executed lease agreement, you have no statutory basis to treat their intake funds as a forfeited security deposit.
Constructing a Defensible Rejection Record
When a denied applicant pushes back, challenges focus on consistency: did the landlord hold this applicant to a different standard than others, or formulate criteria after reviewing the file?
In tenant disputes, an evidentiary gap often works against the property owner. Tenants can draw upon legal aid clinics trained to identify procedural defects in notices or recordkeeping. An owner relying on memory or unorganized messages enters small claims court or administrative hearings without backing.
To establish a defensible rejection process, implement three operational controls:
- Publish Objective Rental Criteria First: Texas Property Code Chapter 92 governs residential tenancies across Texas. Before collecting an application fee or deposit, establish written qualification thresholds covering minimum credit scores, income-to-rent ratios, and verified rental history. State screening rules and legally recognized protected classes require careful alignment; review TX Tenant Criminal Screening & Fair Housing Rules to keep your standards aligned with state and federal guidelines.
- Log Rejection Data Concurrently: Record the precise statutory basis for rejection the moment the decision is reached. If the applicant fell short of your documented income threshold, log the verified monthly income, the required income multiple, and the exact shortfall.
- Preserve FCRA Delivery Records: Archive a dated copy of the written adverse action notice, the consumer reporting agency disclosures, any credit score attachments, and the electronic delivery confirmation. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, delivering these disclosures defends against statutory claims of willful noncompliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I tell an applicant they were rejected over the phone?
While 15 U.S.C. § 1681m permits oral notice of an adverse action, relying on phone conversations leaves no auditable record of statutory performance. If an applicant alleges they were never notified of their dispute rights under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i or their right to a free report under § 1681j, an oral conversation offers zero evidentiary defense. Always provide written or electronic adverse action notices.
What if an applicant fails to provide a forwarding address for their application deposit refund?
Under Texas Property Code § 92.351 (last checked March 2025), application deposits are refundable upon rejection. You should request a refund address or return application deposits electronically via the original payment method immediately upon rejection.
If an applicant lied on their application, can I keep the application deposit?
Texas Property Code § 92.351 specifies that an application deposit is refundable if the applicant is rejected as a tenant. Unless your written application contains explicit, legally enforceable language establishing contractual damages for fraudulent application submissions, retaining an application deposit exposes you to statutory wrongful retention claims under Texas law. You may retain the nonrefundable application fee to cover vetting expenses.
Do FCRA requirements apply if I self-manage only one rental home?
Yes. The Fair Credit Reporting Act does not contain a small-landlord exemption. Any person who takes an adverse action against a consumer based in whole or in part on information in a consumer report must deliver the notice and disclosure provisions of 15 U.S.C. § 1681m.
What this does not cover
This article does not address local municipal tenant protection ordinances or federal bankruptcy stay provisions.